SUMMARY

Taylor and Kelly sit down with Jay Ernest, lead singer of Church of Cash and co-creator of Folsom Prison Experience, an immersive theatrical recreation of Johnny Cash’s legendary 1968 live album recorded at Folsom State Prison. Jay traces his path from playing four-hour sets for tips at an Irish bar in Honolulu to discovering his voice sounded uncannily like Johnny Cash, launching the first Church of Cash in 2009, and eventually relocating to Minnesota, where the band played Tuesday nights at a local bar for $35 split five ways. From there, Jay built Church of Cash into a full-time touring act, landing a European booking agent in 2015 and selling out shows overseas for more than a decade.

The conversation shifts to Folsom Prison Experience, the immersive show Jay created with his business partner, Tom Pickard, during the COVID shutdown. Rather than a standard tribute concert, the show places the audience inside Folsom State Prison itself, complete with inmate numbers, in-character guards working the aisles, and a set list built almost entirely from what Johnny Cash actually played that day.

A major thread of the episode is the show’s rebrand. As Folsom Prison Experience grew, Jay realized his original website no longer reflected the quality of what audiences were actually seeing on stage. Taylor and Kelly walk through what that project looked like from Moxie’s side: building a website designed to deliver “the show before the show,” commissioning original illustration work for a movie-poster feel, and producing a printed program audiences now take home as a keepsake. Jay is candid about what it means for a business owner to hand a creative vision to a team and trust the process, and how the finished brand changed the way audiences and venues perceive the show before a single ticket is scanned.